heya greenday - I've played several games with/against you on my cheesus account. Glad to see you popping up here on the forums.
Win percentages really don't mean jack when they're in the high 50's and 60's.
I agree somewhat. I don't think I've ever been impressed by a super high win rate (and I'd hope no one all that experienced with the game would be either), as it typically is a clear sign of people doing a wee bit of stacking or some sort of nonsense. I do generally find that most folks with > 1,000 games and that are > 50ish% win rate are decent. Its just that the total games played number is more valuable than win % - not all agree with me, of course, and there are always exceptions.
As for that host cheat crap. I think it's pretty lame and I can't believe Ruip used that dirty tactic. Inexorable used that on me and my partners 2 days ago and god knows how many more times it was used on me since I was not aware of it. I really don't check my stats that often to keep track. All those games I was winning only to be counted as lossess due to cheating and critical errors.
With regards to rui, 2-3 folks reported him last week and I checked into it. After discussing things with him, I personally don't believe he's intentionally using any exploit, but his connection can be a little problematic - which is leading to the issues that were reported. He linked me to a pantheon game that he played in recently where everyone was dc'd from him and he himself ended up with a loss (I've never even seen something like that - normally the host would get the win with all dc'd). I gave him some extra info on how to improve his connections stability, but I'm not sure if he's looked into it. Anyway, the bottom line is that I don't think he's pulling any cheating nonsense, but at the same time, unless he changes some of his connection settings, you might not want him to host any games or join games that he is the host if you care about stats.