The new Galaxy Forge is supposed to have an editable objective thing, which would allow modders to create a campaign,  such as the one I'm thinking about for the Darkness.

And by "not perfect" you mean "very bad", I'm sure.

Old man ranting!

From: Brandon Rogers
Question: Will there ever be a campaign?

Answer: Yes, just not in the Sins 1 series. We are looking to add some more interesting scenarios in Rebellion, however.

So does that mean that there will be a Sins II and it might have campaign?

campaign for rebelion would be VERY cool, especially since there than can be a boss(superuberduperwtfgraping titan) which would be the only thing i would actually play the campaign for, just to grape that sun-of-a-b*tch with an epic army

*actually, i can make that ubertitan already by changing some stats when i get rebelion

They have to to re-do the engine for multi-core processors for sins 2 then make an epic campaign with the head room they have to achieve an awesome experience through gameplay and graphics. 

Its what i'd do right now.

It is with a small cry of joy that I read that the devs are working on better tutorials.

I suggest that Sins is a very hard game to learn. I also play Civ 3 and 4. Now those games you maybe watch a couple video, turn the difficulty down to self destructive moron for AI and start playing. Presently you are pretty good. It is all there for you to see and you get immediate feedback on everything you do.

1. Better tutorials are part of the answer.

2. The second part is fairly easy. A series of videos on youtube either by the devs or good players with fraps. The videos walk the new player through starting a game. I'm doing this so that I can do that. Explain each step. Then a video on basic strategy and tactics for each race. Then perhaps several videos on tips and tricks. Or just "what I like to do" videos. These will help a lot. I think the videos would be fun to make. I mean hopefully they are so that the joy of playing can infect the new player.

The current method of throwing people in and trusting that they iwll learn to swim just stinks. It results in a lot of unhappy new players, bad buzz, and a small player base.

Well, part of campaigns is showing people what to do in those first few missions.  But the result of past couple of years is unhappy new players, bored old players, and a really small MP base.  However, with the 'Throw them in the empty pool and see if they can fly' method has given rise to a very active modding community.

Hydra, you can only do so much with a 1 minute cutscene.

If I recall, Starcraft 1 had a fairly good campaign.

It's more than possible.

I really really hate comments like these. Most RTS campaign suck, I understand that, but you cant just act like a little child and be like "NOOS! THE DEVZELOPSERS SAYS DAT DER IS NOT GON TO BE CAMPAAAAYYN ENDZ OF DA STORYEYZ! CAMPAYNZ IZ DUMB!"

So... you wanna be a good boy and do whats yer supposed to do is that right? Aww thats so cute /sarcasm.

The developers should ask themselves: "Will cost of making a campaign be worth it?"

It will never reduce sales of the game, it can only increase sales by... 10% maybe 20%?

I don't personally care about it. I will spend most of the time smashing my friend online

Man, what's wrong with you? I'm just stating the fact that the developers are not doing a campaign for Rebellion. It has nothing to do with maturity levels (which you seem to be lacking in). So many of your posts seem to be made for the sole purpose of insulting others.

And I never said I'm against a campaign - in fact, I think it would be a great way to guide newer players along the more basic elements of strategy. It's just that the developers are certainly not implementing a campaign for Rebellion, as they've repeated many times.